1 like 1 dislike
by (150 points)

14 Answers

0 like 0 dislike
by Newbie (340 points)

This student's claim that drinking large amounts of water can cure or prevent the COVID19 virus is false and extremely misleading. I was not able to find any accurate and reliable sources to support this claim, and instead found multiple credible health sources, such as the World Health Organization and John Hopkins, stating that it does not kill the virus or prevent infection. Although drinking water can help relieve specific symptoms like sore throats or dehydration, the COVID virus enters the body through the nose and respiratory system, which are ways that water cannot stop.

My Sources:

1. World Health Organization Infographic:

https://www.who.int/vietnam/emergencies/covid-19-in-vietnam/information/mythbusters 

Clearly states that drinking water does not prevent coronavirus infection.

2. John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health 

https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2020/covid-19-myths-vs-realities 

Includes expert statements. One says that while warm water or gargling may soothe a sore throat, it has "no direct effect on the virus". It also says that there is "no evidence at all for the specific claim that "You can avoid the virus by drinking warm water every 15 minutes."

3. BBC

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200319-covid-19-will-drinking-water-keep-you-safe-from-coronavirus 

In this article it talks about how there is no scientific research supporting the claim and that believing it can cause a false sense of security.

Possible Biases:

BBC: The only possible bias I could think of, as both The World Health Organization and John Hopkins are incredibly reliable sources, was with BBC. As a news website BBC may present information in a more engaging way in order to gain traction, but it still relies on scientific evidence. 

False
0 like 0 dislike
by Newbie (390 points)

This claim is false. With covid 19 being a respiratory virus, it's not possible for it to be flushed out of your system with water. From an article posted by the BCC, they stated that "The logic is that this will help to wash the virus down the oesophagus, so it that it can be killed by our stomach acid." Even reading this article, this claim is totally misleading. Although there isn't fully a cure, there are highly effective treatments for Covid. This being seen through vaccines, antiviral medications, support, etc, and drinking water was not one of them. Although drinking water is highly recommended (anytime) when you're sick, it's important to drink water daily. Staying hydrated when you're sick is incredibly important because it regulates your body temperature, and with a regulated body temperature that means it so your metabolic process is functioning to its highest level. Drinking water is not something that can cure covid, but it can help you stay healthy for your future while also preventing future illnesses. 

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200319-covid-19-will-drinking-water-keep-you-safe-from-coronavirus

https://www.bcbsm.mibluedaily.com/stories/prevention/how-hydration-plays-a-role-in-getting-over-sickness

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK507838/

False
0 like 0 dislike
ago by Newbie (300 points)

The claim, drinking water can cure Covid-19 is very misleading. Yes, drinking water can help the immune system function and relieve illness, it is not the reason someone gets over the virus. Water does not kill the virus.

According to BBCKalpana Sabapathy, a clinical epidemiologist at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine explains,  "infections often begin after we’ve been exposed to thousands or millions of viral particles, so sweeping a few down the oesophagus is unlikely to have much of an impact. “One gaping hole in it is the likelihood that you managed to flush all of them down into your stomach,” she says. “You would probably have already got them in your nostrils by then, for example – it’s not fool proof,” she says. And here lies another of the main flaws in the idea. Even if the virus hasn’t already managed to find its way inside the cells of your respiratory tract, it can also get into the body in other ways. While some people might become infected by touching their mouth with contaminated fingers, it can also enter the body by touching the nose or eyes." Kalpana Sabapathy argument reveals how drinking water will not be affective because the virus can access the body through the eyes or nostrils as well. Water will not be affective and even if the infection accessed through the mouth, water will have little to no impact. 

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200319-covid-19-will-drinking-water-keep-you-safe-from-coronavirus

In addition, ABC News debunks the myth that water gets rid of the virus, this article states, "There is no current scientific evidence behind the claim that keeping your mouth moist will prevent infection with coronavirus. But staying hydrated can help keep your immune system strong." "The temperature of the water you drink is not important, however, drinking water and staying hydrated is important for many reasons. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, water helps your body with a number of functions, including regulating body temperature."

Dr. Simone Wildes, an infectious disease specialist at South Shore Hospital in Boston agrees: "Hydration is always good; it helps with all bodily functions."

"People can usually meet their fluid needs by drinking water when they are feeling thirsty and drinking with meals. Your body requires more water when you are running a fever, are more physically active or have diarrhea or vomiting." This article states how water itself will not kill the virus, but drinking lots of water to stay hydrated will help your immune system fight off the virus. 

https://abcnews.com/Health/debunking-myths-avoid-cure-coronavirus/story?id=69578209

To counter those points above, AP News suggests, "False. Drinking water prevents dehydration, but it will not prevent anyone from catching the new coronavirus." "THE FACTS: Doctors caution against believing homegrown advice that social media users are spreading online as ways of preventing the virus. Dr. William Schaffner, an infectious disease expert at Vanderbilt University, said while medical professionals typically recommend keeping up fluid intake when sick, drinking more water will not keep anyone from catching the virus."

“We always caution anyone healthy and people who are sick to keep up fluid intake and keep mucus membranes moist,” he said. “It makes you feel better, there is no clear indication that it directly protects you against complications.” Dr. William Schaffner clearly states how drinking water will not prevent someone from getting the virus, but it can help fight off the virus and "keeps the mucus membranes moist." He claims that like any other illness that fluid intake is important for fighting a virus, but does not kill a virus. 

https://apnews.com/article/8551030197

In addition, a fact or fiction article from the The World Health Organization claims, "There is no evidence that drinking lots of water flushes out the new coronavirus.However, for good health in general, it is recommended that people should have 8 glasses of water every day." The world health organization reveals how drinking water does not flush out coronavirus, but for overall health, drinking 8 glasses of water can keep someone healthy. Staying healthy can prevent the coronavirus or lessen the effects of the virus, but water cannot get rid of the virus. 

https://www.who.int/southeastasia/outbreaks-and-emergencies/covid-19/What-can-we-do-to-keep-safe/fact-or-fiction

To conclude, an article from Universitas Gadjah Mada, reveals, "Internal Medicine Expert (Intern Pulmonologist) FKKMK UGM, dr. Sumardi, Sp.PD, KP., FINASIM., firmly denied claims of drinking hot water, and taking a hot shower could kill Covid-19." He explained that hot water, whether consumed or for bathing, would not be able to reach or kill the virus because the Covid-19 virus is ensconced in the body’s cells. Meanwhile, the body will automatically regulate its temperature when getting a virus attack."

“If a virus enters the body, the body temperature will rise by itself to neutralize the virus. So, there is no need to drink or take a hot shower because it will disrupt the body system,” Sumardi explained." Even though this article talks about hot water, Dr. Sumardi claims that water will not kill the virus no matter what temperature. The body will just adapt to neutralize the virus. If anything, drinking hot water can cause more harm than good because it will disrupt the bodies natural function of getting the virus out. 

https://ugm.ac.id/en/news/19427-ugm-expert-hot-water-cannot-eradicate-covid-19-within-the-body-s-cells/

Exaggerated/ Misleading
0 like 0 dislike
ago by Newbie (300 points)

I found that the claim drinking large amounts of water can cure COVID-19 is false. Drinking water is important for staying hydrated, but there is no evidence that drinking large amounts of it can cure or flush COVID-19 from the body. The research also showed me how information spread through media can influence what people believe, especially during a health crisis.

The who directly addresses the claim that drinking lots of water can flush out the coronavirus. It states that there is no evidence that drinking lots of water flushes out the virus, although drinking enough water is recommended for general health.

The CDC explains that people at higher risk for severe COVID-19 can receive antiviral medications. Water is not listed as a treatment or cure, which provides strong evidence against the original claim.

The BBC investigated the rumor that drinking water frequently could wash the coronavirus into the stomach where stomach acid would kill it. The article explains that there is no scientific evidence supporting this idea and that the virus can infect the body before drinking water could have such an effect.

Mayo Clinic explains that claims about foods, drinks, or other substances preventing or treating COVID-19 are not supported by evidence. It also explains that people should rely on proven COVID-19 medicines and guidance from healthcare professionals rather than untested home remedies.

False

Community Rules


• Be respectful
• Always list your sources and include links so readers can check them for themselves.
• Use primary sources when you can, and only go to credible secondary sources if necessary.
• Try to rely on more than one source, especially for big claims.
• Point out if sources you quote have interests that could affect how accurate their evidence is.
• Watch for bias in sources and let readers know if you find anything that might influence their perspective.
• Show all the important evidence, whether it supports or goes against the claim.
...